Is the Boundary Waters a place for Man's Best Friend?

Tuesday, May 10, 2011 by Sue Prom
     If a man's best friend is his dog then he's in trouble no matter where he goes! But seriously dogs and family pets are very important members of the family and some people would rather stay home than go somewhere without their pet.  While I love my dog I do leave him home sometimes but he usually comes along when I go on a canoe camping trip in the Boundary Waters.
     My dog has grown up at Voyageur Canoe Outfitters in the wilderness where loons call, moose mosy and fish splash next to the canoe.  Even with all of his canoe time he is still an animal and an unpredictable one at that. 
      Last year I was paddling a canoe in the BWCA with my nieces and Rugby decided to take a leap for Josh who was in a kayak next to us.  Rugby had never jumped from a canoe before and we have no clue what possessed him to do it that day but he did.  We struggled in the wind and the waves to scoop him back into the canoe and thankfully we didn't tip in the process.
     Things could have turned out differently had we capsized the canoe or kayak in the Boundary Waters.  I was responsible for my two nieces, my daughter, my son and my dog.  The water and air temperature were warm and we were close to shore however I risked the safety of my people family to save my dog.
     Every time I hike a BWCA portage or let my dog off the leash at a wilderness campsite I risk losing him.  If he gets on the trail of a moose, deer or grouse he could easily become hurt, lost or worse.  It's very sad to see a sign at a BWCA canoe landing that announces a lost dog.  It could happen very easily and I worry about his well-being and how I would feel if something happened to him.
     With all decisions you must weigh the risks versus the benefits.  Is having your pet along worth risking his safety or a fellow paddler's safety? That's for you to decide.

BWCA dogs in the wilderness



Consider the following when deciding whether or not to bring your dog into the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness.

     Taking responsibility for your dog is a necessity if you want to bring it into the BWCA wilderness with you. You must protect other visitors, wildlife, the wilderness and the dog itself. The owner must be responsible for picking up after their pet, keeping the dog quiet, making sure the dog doesn’t harass wildlife or defecate at campsites, dig up lichen or get into someone’s packs at a portage. The dog may always stay at your side while walking in a park but on a wilderness portage it may not act the same when it is unfamiliar with its surroundings. Even if the dog is leashed it can escape with the leash on and become tangled in brush, injured or worse yet, it can become lost in the wild never to be seen again. 

Comments for Is the Boundary Waters a place for Man's Best Friend?

Tuesday, May 10, 2011 by Jan Kitzing:
I don't mean to stomp on other peoples fun, but I am. We are dogless people and would rather hear nature when out in the wilderness. On portage trails, or even backpacking or just day hiking, if the dog has strayed away from its people, I would not know if it is a "wild" dog, lost, or...if it started following me, should I let it? Would I have to stop so it's owners can find it? I think dogs should be left with a friend or a kennel.
Saturday, May 14, 2011 by Bob McNutt:
Dog's and there people have the RIGHT to all the same areas unless posted (no dogs) . See you on the trail with my DOGS.
Thursday, May 19, 2011 by Ritalee Walters:
I don't have a lot of experience in the BWCA, but I'm pro-dog, especially Rugby!
Monday, June 20, 2011 by AC:
I have a 60 lb dog and a 5 lb dog, is it too risky to bring my little toy poodle? I worry about eagles or falcons overhead. She wears her very bright orange life jacket the whole time. We had some owls and other birds flying over her in the UP but she was just fine. Thoughts? I also heard she should not swim because of large fish or snappy turtles that may try to eat her? Thoughts? Thank you!!
Tuesday, July 5, 2011 by Ed:
It's self-indulgent to bring dogs into the wilderness. It's somewhat low class to impose on others (no different than smoking). I get more irritated at the owners CONSTANTLY yelling at dogs. Be a little considerate to others (and nature) and leave the dog at home, please.
Tuesday, May 14, 2013 by Kate:
"It's self-indulgent to bring dogs into the wilderness": really? Do you also feel imposed upon by the loons hooting late at night? Being in the wilderness is a lesson in how small and powerless humans really are, relative to the forces of nature. If you want a specific and controlled experience, then the great outdoors isn't the place for you, Ed.

Leave a comment





Captcha